| Date | Teams/Event | Time | Score | Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|
April | ||||
| Sat. 15 | VS Ohio Dominican * ^ | Final | L, 8-5 | Box Score Video |
| VS Ohio Dominican * ^ | Final | L, 15-7 | Recap Box Score Box Score | |
| Wed. 19 | AT Saginaw Valley | Final | L, 4-1 | Recap Box Score |
| Sat. 22 | AT Trevecca Nazarene * ^ | Final | W, 8-3 | Box Score |
| AT Trevecca Nazarene * ^ | Final - 7 innings | L, 12-0 | Recap Game 2 Box Game 1 Box | |
| Sun. 23 | AT Trevecca Nazarene * ^ | Final - 7 innings | W, 2-1 | Box Score Video |
| AT Trevecca Nazarene * ^ | Final | L, 12-11 | Recap Game 2 Box Game 1 Box Video | |
| Sat. 29 | VS Ky. Wesleyan * ^ | Final | W, 11-1 | Box Score Video |
| VS Ky. Wesleyan * ^ | Final - 7 innings | W, 4-0 | Recap Box Game 2 Box Game 1 Video | |
| Sun. 30 | VS Ky. Wesleyan * ^ | Final | W, 8-4 | Box Score Video |
| VS Ky. Wesleyan * ^ | Final | W, 11-8 | Recap Box Game 2 Box Game 1 Video | |
May | ||||
| Fri. 5 | AT Cedarville * ^ | Final | W, 13-3 | Box Score |
| AT Cedarville * ^ | Final | W, 4-0 | Recap Game 1 Box Game 2 Box | |
| Sat. 6 | AT Cedarville * ^ | Final | W, 9-3 | Box Score |
| AT Cedarville * ^ | Final | W, 8-2 | Recap Box Score | |
| Wed. 10 | VS Hillsdale % @ Mason, Ohio | Final | L, 7-6 | Recap Box Score |
| 2023 G-MAC Tournament | ||||
| Thu. 11 | VS Ky. Wesleyan % @ Mason, Ohio | Final | W, 5-0 | Box Score |
| G-MAC Tournament | ||||
| VS Walsh % @ Mason, Ohio | Final | W, 5-3 | Recap Box Score | |
| Fri. 12 | VS Trevecca Nazarene % @ Legacy Field | Final | W, 3-2 | Box Score Video |
| 2023 G-MAC Consolation Semifinal | ||||
| VS Northwood % @ Mason, Ohio | Final | L, 8-3 | Recap Box Score Video | |
| 2023 G-MAC Consolation Final | ||||
* Conference
^ Division
% Postseason